This holiday season, I had the opportunity to participate in the “Great Food Blogger Cookie Swap!” ![]()
To participate in the cookie swap, each blogger baked three dozen of their favorite baked good. We were each sent a list of 3 different bloggers to mail our cookies to. And then each of us received cookies from 3 other bloggers. So it was kind of a “Secret Santa” event. ![]()
We were told to ship out our cookies no later than Monday December 5th. So on three different days last week, I was the lucky recipient of some delicious cookies! ![]()
Cookie Delivery #1:
I was sent cookies from an actual pastry chef?? How lucky could a girl be??
These cookies were pistachio shortbread cookies with clementine marmalade. I’m not typically a big shortbread fan, but I was very impressed with these cookies. I loved the combination of flavors and textures. I was also impressed with how pretty they were! Thank you, Rachel, for your very creative cookies!
Cookie Delivery #2:
Kristina sent me some “old-fashioned sour cream cookies.”
I gotta be honest. Flavor-wise, these cookies were my personal favorite. They were soft and spongy and tasted a lot like a snickerdoodle, which I love. Thanks, Kristina, for your super tasty cookies! ![]()
Cookie Delivery #3:
Teri sent me her family’s favorite holiday cookies …
… Mint Chocolate Truffle Cookies!
Not only were the cookies unique and tasty, but I also loved the card Teri sent me. She wrote a very kind and personal message. Thank you so much, Teri!!
—————–
So by now, you’re probably wondering what cookies I sent for the swap!
I actually decided to be a rebel and sent brownies instead of cookies. ![]()
I figured the brownies would hold up well during shipping, and they would still taste fresh after a couple of days on a delivery truck.
Plus, these brownies contained two of my favorite ingredients ever.
Peanut butter and Nutella. Doesn’t get much better, folks.
The recipe is called “Peanut Butter-Hazelnut Brownies.”
I used this recipe from Food Network and I followed it to a “T.”
Note: If any of you can actually melt peanut butter and Nutella together and not lick the bowl clean … well, you are a better person than me.
One note about the baking time. I have made these several times in the past and I have noticed that if you use a glass baking dish, you’ll need to bake the brownies a little longer (30-35 minutes). But if you use a dark metal pan,you will probably need to bake the brownies for less time (closer to 25 minutes). Just keep that in mind, and be sure to use a toothpick to check their doneness.
As I mentioned, I have made these brownies a lot in the past. And they are always a huge crowd-pleaser.
They are incredibly rich, moist, and flavorful. They are also addicting … just a warning. ![]()
I had never shipped baked goods before, but fortunately the cookie swap hosts (Julie and Lindsay) had given us some advice in this area!
I bought these cute plastic containers at Walmart for a minimal cost. Then I cut out parchment paper and put it on the bottom of each container. I put six brownies in the bottom of the container, put more parchment on top of those brownies, and added six more brownies before putting on the lid.
I used plastic bags …
… and bubble wrap …
… to keep the container of brownies from moving around in the box. Then I just taped up the box and shipped it!
One of the bloggers who received my brownies said that they were perfect when she received them, which I was very relieved to hear! So I guess my first cookie swap was a success!! ![]()
Question for ya …
If you are a blogger, did you participate in the swap? What cookies did you make?
If you aren’t a blogger, have you ever participated in a normal cookie swap?
What is your favorite kind of Christmas cookie?
What did you do this weekend??



These sound incredible! Wow! I want to make some Nutella brownies now. Unfortunately, I’ve placed an embargo on holiday baking during the weeks between the cookie swap and Christmas. Now I’m not sure I can make it!
Kristina recently posted..Ice cream Christmas trees, and a recipe contest
Kristina, I seriously LOVED your cookies. And they lasted so long! I just ate the last two tonight haha!
Thanks again!
Those look Ah.Ma.Zing. PB and Nutella? Sign me up! Can you share the recipe? Would it be weird to do a cookie/brownie swap with myself?

Cinnamon @ eatpraytri recently posted..Score!
You just have to click on the link I provided to get the recipe. It’s on foodtv.com.
ahhh I totally missed that! Thanks!
Cinnamon @ eatpraytri recently posted..Score!
You’re very welcome!!
You got a pastry chef to make you cookies!? You lucky lady!
I wanted to participate but didn’t because of my wheat allergy
No bueno.
Brittany @ Itty Bits of Balance recently posted..Treat Time
They had other people with dietary restrictions! I think they were trying to match people up based on their restrictions. But I do understand. Honestly it was fun, but also a lot of work and money to ship them. You take the good with the bad, right?
Those brownies are calling my name…. YUM!
I co-hosted my first cookie swap this past Saturday night. It was a “cookies and cocktails” party, and we had a great time. I think my pants are fitting a little tight after eating all those sweet treats.
I decided to be a rebel and make truffles. I made “dark chocolate Bailey’s Caramel Irish Cream truffles” and didn’t really have a set recipe to follow, but MAN they were good.
Hopefully next year I can do the blogger cookie swap – how fun!
Wow those truffles sound amazing!!!
Holy crap those brownies look AMAZING…I might be using this recipe to give to my co-workers! Thanks for sharing

Amy@ahealthyandhappyheart recently posted..Pregnancy: Week 14
looks like these turned out awesome! how fun was the cookie swap?! i had such a blast getting to know new food bloggers, and, oh yeah, eating lots of cookies. glad you enjoyed it, too!
amy @ fearless homemaker recently posted..chai snickerdoodle cookies (+ the great food blogger cookie swap!)
Oh man, I am seriously jealous of all these cookie swaps I’ve been seeing! Why oh why did I not participate? You lucky girl

Kiah recently posted..weekend of pictures
Bahh I’m so sad that I didn’t participate in this!! I WANT some cookies haha…actually I really want those brownies that you made. Seriously they look and sound fantastic! I’m hardcore craving chocolate right now
.
I didn’t participate, but it looks like fun! Your brownies look so good…I think I might have to try that recipe
.
Emily @ Perfection Isn’t Happy recently posted..Christmas Angels in Indiana
Definitely try the brownies … you won’t regret it! But plan to give some to neighbors or co-workers, or else you’ll end up eating them all in 24 hours (if you are like me!).
love the idea of the swap! i think the sour cream cookies would be my fave

Sam recently posted..5 ways to find balance this season
I wanted to participate SO bad but knew I had a ton of obligations coming up and would be pressed for time and didnt want to disappoint!! SO, next year
Love reading about it on everyones blogs though!
I love good ol fashioned sugar cookies, snickerdoodles, or my new fav I made this year brownie mint cookies (I will be sharing soon!)
Yum, all of the cookies sound great!